Artículos

  • Ordenar resultados

  • Cantidad de resultados por página

  • Líneas de investigación

 

 

Since the beginning of the research on the family business and rural economy, there has been a problem with the delimitation of the concepts. Given this problem, this study’s main objective was to identify and visualize the intellectual structure of these two issues through scientific maps. To meet this objective, an evaluation of scientific performance and production was carried out with bibliometric indicators to extract the main research topics around these two areas through an analysis of the co-occurrence of keywords with scientific maps. The results show that research on family businesses and rural economy is booming, especially on family businesses that have higher productivity and performance. Regarding the main topics studied regarding family businesses and the rural economy, a total of 16 main themes were detected, highlighting the topic of entrepreneurship. The study of land management in transboundary environments is a potential line of future research.

 

 

Solid-state batteries (SSBs) offer significant improvements in safety, energy density, and cycle life over conventional lithium-ion batteries, with promising applications in electric vehicles and grid storage due to their non-flammable electrolytes and high-capacity lithium metal anodes. However, challenges such as interfacial resistance, low ionic conductivity, and manufacturing scalability hinder their commercial viability. This study conducts a comprehensive scientometric analysis, examining 131 peer-reviewed SSB research articles from IEEE Xplore and Web of Science databases to identify key thematic areas and bibliometric patterns driving SSB advancements. Through a detailed analysis of thematic keywords and publication trends, this study uniquely identifies innovations in high-ionic-conductivity solid electrolytes and advanced cathode materials, providing actionable insights into the persistent challenges of interfacial engineering and scalable production, which are critical to SSB commercialization. The findings offer a roadmap for targeted research and strategic investments by researchers and industry stakeholders, addressing gaps in long-term stability, scalable production, and high-performance interface optimization that are currently hindering widespread SSB adoption. The study reveals key advances in electrolyte interface stability and ion transport mechanisms, identifying how solid-state electrolyte modifications and cathode coating methods improve charge cycling and reduce dendrite formation, particularly for high-energy-density applications. By mapping publication growth and clustering research themes, this study highlights high-impact areas such as cycling stability and ionic conductivity. The insights from this analysis guide researchers toward impactful areas, such as electrolyte optimization and scalable production, and provide industry leaders with strategies for accelerating SSB commercialization to extend electric vehicle range, enhance grid storage, and improve overall energy efficiency.

 

 

The marketing technology ecosystem is rapidly evolving, integrating digital tools and platforms to transform marketing practices. This study analyses this dynamic and diverse field, addressing research trends, theoretical foundations and future directions. This research uses a multimethod approach combining bibliometric analysis, systematic literature review and content analysis. The study analyzed 144 articles from 2017 to 2024, using the theory, context, characteristics and method (TCCM) framework to structure the findings. Key research themes include artificial intelligence (AI), blockchain, digital marketing and customer experience. Journals like Industrial Marketing Management dominate the field, with the United States and the United Kingdom (UK) leading in publications; theoretical foundations focus on service-dominant logic (SDL), digital transformation, and ecosystem perspectives. Commonly used theories include technology acceptance models and dynamic capabilities, applied across various industries and digital platforms. Research methods range from quantitative surveys to qualitative case studies and emerging AI-driven analytics. The study highlights the field’s rapid evolution and diverse, interdisciplinary nature, combining various perspectives and expertise. Exciting future research directions include integrating emerging technologies, exploring sustainability and ethical implications, and developing more sophisticated, multimethod approaches to capture the complexity of marketing technology ecosystems.

 

 

Objective: To characterize the articles published in the Finlay journal during the period between 2011 and 2022. Materials and methods: An observational, descriptive, bibliometric study was carried out on the articles published in the Finlay journal. The universe consisted of 525 articles. Sampling techniques were not used. The analyzed variables were number of articles, year of publication, number of authors, origin of the authors, type of article, main theme of the articles, type of study, number of references, number of 5-year-old references, number of citations per article and number of citations received by the journal per year. A descriptive statistics and bibliometrics were used. Results: The year 2021 stood out with 60 research works (11.38 %). Articles with three authors prevailed (155; 29.52 %), Cienfuegos stood out with 1,074 authors (59.40 %) and original articles (OA) predominated (243; 46.28 %). Images in medicine (IM) had the highest Price’s Index (0.80). Among the OA, research works with an observational-descriptive approach prevailed (225 published articles, which accounted for 92.59 % out of the total number of OA). Research related to cardiovascular diseases predominated (116; 22.09 %). A total of 4,870 citations were received, most of them from 2017, with a number of corrected citations (NCC) of 38.3. Meanwhile, the year 2020 had an impact factor (IF) of 3.27. Conclusions: The Finlay journal is a scientific body for the dissemination of research results with extensive achievements and experiences in editorial management. Its growth has been exponential in terms of the number of articles published, prevailing the year 2021. Its issues include research works that show the collaboration between national and foreign authors, highlighting the results of the Cienfuegos province’s researchers. In this regard, the topics focus on health problems that are included in the sector’s priority health programs, based on original research to a greater extent and coupled with a higher number of citations received especially in 2017.

 

 

The need for sophisticated traceability systems has become essential in increasingly complex and globalized supply chains. The convergence of Blockchain (BC), Internet of Things (IoT), and Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies offers promising solutions to enhance traceability systems across various sectors, particularly supply chain management (SCM). This paper presents a comprehensive bibliometric and systematic literature review to explore emerging trends, research patterns, and methodologies in integrating BC, IoT, and AI into traceability systems. In the study, 530 documents from the SCOPUS database for bibliometric analysis were examined, alongside a detailed review of 43 selected articles from multiple databases. The findings highlighted a significant increase in research output in recent years, with a dominant focus on agricultural supply chains and SCM. Notably, India and China lead the field in publications and citations. Furthermore, key authors and influential journals significantly contributed to advancing the research. The analysis also revealed a predominance of experimental and hybrid research methodologies, with Ethereum and Hyperledger Fabric emerging as the most widely adopted platforms for system implementations. The study identified critical research trends, including the growing role of AI-driven analytics, the importance of real-time IoT data collection, and the critical need for secure, tamper-proof data provided by BC. However, challenges, such as interoperability, scalability, and standardization, remain hindering the widespread adoption of these technologies. The paper proposes a four-layer conceptual framework for integrating BC, IoT, and AI into future traceability systems, emphasizing their potential to enhance transparency, security, and efficiency across various application areas. The paper concludes by offering directions for future research, highlighting the need for more empirical studies, industry-specific frameworks, and standardization to overcome existing limitations.

 

 

High entropy ceramics (HECs) represent a novel class of materials characterized by their unique multi-principal element compositions and exceptional properties. This study investigates the mechanical and thermal properties of high entropy ceramics through a comprehensive bibliometric analysis of 395 Scopus-indexed articles. Biblioshiny, VOSviewer and Gephi software are used to analyze different data linked with these articles. Data from abstracts are analyzed to identify properties like thermal conductivity, hardness, fracture toughness, etc Computer vision has been applied in data extraction and property characterization of HEC. Investigation reveals significant insights into the co-occurrence of keywords related to various mechanical properties, such as fracture toughness and compressive strength, alongside thermal characteristics like thermal conductivity. Visualizing these relationships highlights research clusters and identifies gaps in the current literature, paving the way for future exploration in this promising field.

 

 

This study conducts a bibliometric analysis of academic papers and conference proceedings related to tablet dispensers, medicine dispensers, and pill dispensers within the framework of Sustainable Development Goal 03: Good Health and Well-Being. The analysis spans literature published between 1997 and 2023. Utilizing the Web of Science database, the study employs keywords such as “tablet dispenser,” “medicine dispenser,” and “pill dispenser” to gather relevant English-language papers classified as Proceeding Papers or Articles. The inclusion and exclusion criteria filtered 79 initial records down to 40, focusing on articles pertinent to SDG 03. Data analysis was performed using the Biblioshiny App through RStudio, examining publication trends, authorship patterns, citation networks, and other bibliometric indicators. The findings reveal a steady increase in research output, moderate citation impact, extensive references, and collaborative authorship, with limited international collaboration. The study underscores the growing interest and research activity in robotic tablet dispensing machines for elderly care while highlighting areas for further global engagement.

 

 

Since it was released in November 2022, ChatGPT has been exerting revolutionary influence on the realm of higher education. In order to obtain a comprehensive understanding of the research landscape, we conduct a systematic literature review on the studies of ChatGPT used in higher education. Both quantitative and qualitative methods were adopted to bibliometrically examine the included literature selected from Web of Science and Scopus through the PRISMA protocol. Tools of VOSviewer and CitNetExplorer were employed to visualize the citation information. Our findings showed that the recent two years witnessed an ever-growing popularity of this research theme. Citation information analysis reveals the most influential authors, countries, sources, organizations and four focused topics. The disciplinary distribution of related research indicates a wide range of categories. More importantly, ChatGPT was found to be versatile in assisting teachers, students and researchers with a variety of tasks, and the factors influencing the acceptance of this technology among college students could be investigated through models like TAM, UTAUT and their extensions. We suggest future studies to focus on the ways to address the limitations and ethical issues of ChatGPT through AI literacy cultivation and joint efforts of all stakeholders.

 

 

Branding has emerged as a multidiscipline with complication, conveyed by integrated digital technologies, AI, and rich linguistic approaches. This paper depicts the research landscape at the juncture of branding and linguistics, supported by VOSviewer, Biblioshiny, and CiteSpace in pinpointing key trends, themes, and collaboration networks. Drawing on data collected from Scopus, this study investigates the shifts in traditional branding strategies caused by technologies of machine learning, sentiment analysis, and social media platforms. It highlights the contributions made by leading authors, major publication sources, and patterns of international collaboration in influential works. Finally, thematic and co-occurrence analysis shows significant movement into data-based and computational approaches. This also points out some research gaps in the field of digital branding’s long-term effects, ethical considerations of AI-photo strategies, and multilingual branding approaches that provide a useful basis for future research and practical application innovation in the field of branding. © 2025, Econjournals.

 

 

The digital technologies are transforming the financial markets and may prove to be a game-changer in terms of attaining SDG objectives over time. As a result, UN agencies have begun to prioritize the utilization of the digital revolution to advance SDGs. There is a growing body of literature on the use of digital money to achieve sustainability objectives. As businesses commit to protecting the environment, natural systems, and society, consumer eco-awareness has elevated the importance of the issue in the field of sustainable digital finance. The rationale behind this study is to unify the fragmented literature on digital money and to present a clear conceptual framework for sustainable digital finance in order to advance sustainability goals. Specifically, the study aims to investigate the evolution of sustainable digital finance through analyzing publication and citation trends, developing an author-country-keyword framework, and exploring the significant themes and subjects emerging from the field of sustainable digital finance. Additionally, the study examines ongoing shifts in the digital finance sector and the digital sustainable revolution, which can help us harness technology for social good (Grand Challenge: social work) and move closer to achieving sustainable development goals. We employ a two-tiered analytic strategy, comprising of bibliometric analysis and an integrated literature evaluation of 168 publications from the Web of Science database. In addition to descriptive and thematic analysis, the findings provide us with seven relevant themes (financial involvement and participation, sustainable financial development, green finance, digital venture capital, fintech, financial performance, and digital strategy) and four prominent aggregate dimensions (digital financial inclusion, digital sustainable revolution, digital financial transformation, and harness technology for social good), which will be included in the conceptual framework for future research endeavors. The paper concludes with the policy implications of the findings.

 

 

Aim: This study aims to evaluate the research movements in the Digital Health topic through the most cited 100 products. Material and Method: Top-100 list was obtained by the help of Web of Science Core Collection (www.webofknowledge.com) database. Bibliometric analysis was employed to analyze the documents in detail in the area in question. Altmetric attention score provided by altmetric analysis was utilized to demonstrate the effect of articles on social media. Multiple linear regression analyses were applied to reveal related factors of Citation Count and Altmetric Attention Score. Results: The most-cited 100 papers in Digital Health topic were observed to be published between 2010 and 2020. Mean and standard deviation of the Citation Counts were 141.4±78. A poor positive association is noted between Citation Count and Altmetric Attention Score (r=0.256, p=0.012). Multiple linear regression analysis findings show that “Q2 level (p=0.050)”, “AAS” (p=0.002”), “Since 2013 Usage Count (p<0.001)” and “Duration after Publication (p=0.002)” are significant factors for Citation Count, while “Page Count (p=0.013)” and “5-Year-IF (p<0.001)” are factors associated with Altmetric Attention Score. Conclusion: The findings provide an opportunity to investigate the most current improvements in Digital Health, and its guidance on research and development offers the exploration gaps to fill over this field.

 

 

The rapid expansion of information technology and the intensification of population aging are two prominent features of contemporary societal development. Investigating older adults’ acceptance and use of technology is key to facilitating their integration into an information-driven society. Given this context, the technology acceptance of older adults has emerged as a prioritized research topic, attracting widespread attention in the academic community. However, existing research remains fragmented and lacks a systematic framework. To address this gap, we employed bibliometric methods, utilizing the Web of Science Core Collection to conduct a comprehensive review of literature on older adults’ technology acceptance from 2013 to 2023. Utilizing VOSviewer and CiteSpace for data assessment and visualization, we created knowledge mappings of research on older adults’ technology acceptance. Our study employed multidimensional methods such as co-occurrence analysis, clustering, and burst analysis to: (1) reveal research dynamics, key journals, and domains in this field; (2) identify leading countries, their collaborative networks, and core research institutions and authors; (3) recognize the foundational knowledge system centered on theoretical model deepening, emerging technology applications, and research methods and evaluation, uncovering seminal literature and observing a shift from early theoretical and influential factor analyses to empirical studies focusing on individual factors and emerging technologies; (4) moreover, current research hotspots are primarily in the areas of factors influencing technology adoption, human-robot interaction experiences, mobile health management, and aging-in-place technology, highlighting the evolutionary context and quality distribution of research themes. Finally, we recommend that future research should deeply explore improvements in theoretical models, long-term usage, and user experience evaluation. Overall, this study presents a clear framework of existing research in the field of older adults’ technology acceptance, providing an important reference for future theoretical exploration and innovative applications.

 

 

Research on consumer ethnocentrism (CE) has increased worldwide in various academic disciplines and business sectors due to the rise of globalization and cross-border trade in goods and services. There are few studies that review the literature on CE, all of which can be improved in terms of their degree of objectivity, systematization and number of publications used. The main objective of this paper is to contribute to the academic literature on CE. A broad spectrum of 670 indexed articles from the union of WoS and Scopus was used. We use R and VOSviewer to process the data. We follow a methodological organization according to the 5 W + 2H review framework, the Scientific Procedures and Rationale for Systematic Reviews of the Literature (SPAR-4-SLR) protocol. A bibliometric analysis of keyword co-occurrence in conjunction with the Theory framework. Context, Characteristics and Methodology (TCCM). There is a growing trend in scientific production, with contributions from 82 countries, 1292 authors and 281 sources, with the United States leading the way, followed by Australia and India. The cognitive structure is made up of topics such as consumer ethnocentrism, country of origin, marketing strategies, branding, consumer behavior in marketing, consumer attitude, and consumer animosity. This work provides an objective and scientifically rigorous basis for reducing researcher bias in literature reviews. In addition, it improves the formulation of marketing and commerce strategies by business or public policy decision-makers. The implications and limitations of the study are presented, and future lines of research are suggested.

 

 

Blockchain technology is emerging as a high-impact solution for the tourism industry, a topic chosen for its growing research relevance and potential to revolutionise the tourism sector in several areas. This study examines how the combination of Blockchain technology and P2P platforms advances sustainability and marketing in the tourism accommodation market. It attempts to fill a gap in the literature by focusing on its application in two areas, namely digital markets and technology, which are expanding. The originality of this research lies in its comprehensive review of blockchain applications in tourism from a practical point of view, which has been largely unexplored in the existing literature. Through a bibliometric review of forty-two papers, various Blockchain applications were identified, such as improving transparency, trust, and efficiency in hotel operations and eliminating intermediaries to reduce costs. The adoption of smart contracts and the use of cryptocurrencies have also emerged as key trends. These findings highlight the transformative potential of Blockchain technology to build trust between hosts and guests, streamline processes, and improve the customer experience. However, they emphasise the need for the careful planning and consideration of the challenges associated with implementing this technology. Future research should further explore the specific applications of Blockchain technology in tourism to optimise its impact on industry and ensure long-term sustainability.

 

 

This study reviews the literature focused on nation brands and brand culture through the innovative combination of latent Dirichlet allocation with a multinomial and unordered discrete choice analysis. Unlike a narrow perspective of bibliometric work, which confines itself to reviewing existing literature within a specific research domain, a broader viewpoint leverages bibliometric analysis to pinpoint potential research opportunities indicative of emerging trends in related fields. Adopting this comprehensive paradigm, the current study scrutinizes 60 articles spanning the timeframe from 1992 to 2021. The analysis discerns six prospective marketing strategies instrumental in propelling a country to global brand prominence: the synergistic integration of country-of-origin and city brands, consumption branding, materialistic branding, green branding, ideological branding, and scientific branding. Notably, environmental branding has assumed a pivotal global role post–2015, while ideological branding represents a more recent trend centered on diligent efforts to invigorate national identity systems. Empirical insights underscore the need of a multidisciplinary approach in the creation of nation brands, suggesting that distinct strategies need not be mutually exclusive. Quantitatively, it is found evidence that covering one additional environmental topic in a study increases (decreases) its likelihood of belonging to the consumption (ideology) cluster by 50.8 (50.6) percentage points, respectively. Strategic recommendations for future national endeavors emphasize the significance of becoming a Stackelberg leader in the race to generate added value. Collectively, these findings underscore that the bibliometric analysis employed to elucidate the evolution of nation brands and brand culture, typically associated with international marketing, unveils two promising niche areas for future research in green finance: green nation brands and green brand culture. The former pertains to asset allocations within green enterprises and environmental sectors, enhancing a country’s symbolic commitment to the burgeoning green paradigm. Meanwhile, the later delves into the internalization of fintech development’s growth and intermediary effects, fostering green innovation, energy efficiency, and green supply chains. This bottom-up approach is geared towards meeting community-based needs and presents valuable avenues for future exploration in the field of green finance.

 

 

Eye tracking plays a crucial role in consumer research. The aim of this work is to present the statuses of studies that used eye tracking as an instrument in consumer research to investigate food from a marketing perspective. For this purpose, a bibliometric review of 118 articles from the Business Source Premier and Web of Science Core Collection database was compiled. The bibliometric review provides information on publication trends, leading authors, collaborative networks, journals, institutions, countries, articles, keywords, and themes investigated. Publications in the research field have appeared since 2011, primarily in Europe, the United States, and Uruguay. Three areas of research streams were identified: (1) how consumers became aware of and chose food, (2) nutritional information and its impact, and (3) how food information and its visual attention led to certain consumer behavior. The bibliographic review summarized past research directions and, thus, identified possibilities for future research streams.

 

 

Crowdfunding has emerged as a versatile funding mechanism, drawing support from diverse contributors. Sustainability has taken center stage, fostering projects that prioritize both environmental and social responsibility. The success of crowdfunding initiatives is intricately tied to the concept of social capital, where the cultivation of trust and collaboration enhances the impact of campaigns. Recognizing the growing importance of crowdfunding in advancing sustainability and acknowledging the pivotal role of social capital, this paper presents a thorough bibliometric analysis. Covering the period from 2014 to 2023, our study examines 119 documents sourced from the Scopus and Web of Science databases, employing the keywords “crowdfunding” and “social capital.” The study employs a robust methodology, utilizing Microsoft Excel for frequency examination, VOSviewer for data visualization, and Harzing Publish or Perish for citation metrics and analysis. Our findings reveal a sustained decade-long growth in publications, with Italy emerging as the foremost contributor to crowdfunding and social capital research. Following closely are China, the United States, and Germany. The analysis goes beyond mere publication metrics, identifying key authorship patterns, collaboration networks, and prolific authors. Furthermore, it sheds light on the most active institutions, preferred journals, and top-cited articles in this field. This study makes a substantial contribution to the ongoing discourse surrounding the intersection of crowdfunding, sustainability, and social capital. By addressing the motivation, literature gap, methodology, and key findings, our analysis stands as a foundational resource for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers alike, providing valuable insights for further exploration in this evolving field.

 

 

Customer retention is crucial for businesses because it ensures the ongoing operation of a company’s activities. Hence, companies must adopt suitable and inventive tactics to maintain customer retention. This study employed bibliometric analysis spanning the past decade to identify factors associated with customer retention that can be observed through data visualization networks, overlays, and density maps. The study involved analyzing a compilation of pertinent journals and scientific publications using the software tools Publish or Perish and VOSviewer. A total of 200 research articles were acquired from Google Scholar and subjected to analysis using the Publish or Perish tool. During the period from 2013 to 2023, there was a variable pattern observed in CR, as evidenced by fluctuations in both the quantity of research articles published and the number of citations received. The network visualization results indicate a strong correlation between customer retention and factors such as customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, and customer relationships. The overlays’ results for price, product, and cost exhibit the darkest colors, specifically purple. Conversely, keywords such as strategy, experience, and corporate image are represented by lighter colors, notably yellow. At that time, the colors that stood out the most were associated with density analysis, such as customer retention and customer satisfaction. In contrast, keywords such as competition, effort, price, challenge, success, and brand appeared less prominent.

 

 

This study analyses greenwashing practices in the banking industry using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) and bibliometric methods. This study aims to identify the key concerns associated with greenwashing in the banking sector and understand the extent to which these concerns have been addressed in academic research over the past decade. This analysis was conducted using the Web of Science and Scopus databases, resulting in 19 articles identified following the PRISMA protocol. The key findings indicate that the concept of greenwashing has gained significant attention, with an increasing number of studies published in recent years. The results of the PRISMA analysis revealed that banks have been accused of greenwashing by overemphasising sustainable policies and their commitment to environmental objectives without implementation. This study provides valuable insights into the nature of greenwashing in the banking industry and offers recommendations for future research.

 

 

The use of chatbots for customer service has gained momentum in recent years. Increasing evidence has shown that chatbots can transform the customer service landscape. Nevertheless, this topic currently lacks adequate bibliometric and visualization research. In order to review and summarise the research on chatbots, the study employs a bibliometric analysis approach to gain a comprehensive understanding of chatbots. The study uses bibliometric analysis of 798 documents sourced from the Scopus database from 2001 to 2022. The combination of biblioshiny (web interface application of Bibliometrix) and VOS viewer software was used to visualize the analysis. The study’s findings reveal three prominent areas in the current research: antecedents of the adoption of chatbots, application of chatbots and behavioural & relational outcomes of the application of chatbots. The future directions and implications have been discussed in the study’s conclusion. © 2024 Ram Arti Publishers. All rights reserved.

 

 

Introduction/Objective: This is a quantitative-qualitative study, exploratory and descriptive, which aimed to identify and analyze the characteristics of scientific publications in green marketing, from 1991 to 2020. Methodology: The corpus of analysis consisted of articles indexed in the bibliographic platform Scopus and analyzed using bibliometric indicators. Results: The results show that in the period investigated, 1,149 articles on the subject were published. The year 2020 had the highest number of articles published (161). The predominant language of publications is English. The United States of America was identified as the most productive country, and with the largest network of international research collaboration. The knowledge area “Business, Management and Accounting” concentrates almost a third of all publications. As for the trend towards collaborative research, 79% of the articles originated were obtained by more than one author. The most productive authors are Polonsky M.J., with fourteen authorships and Chen Y.S., with ten authorships. 498 journals published on green marketing, and “Sustainability” was the journal with the highest number of publications (49). The investigated corpus erected 36,559 citations, with an average of 31.81 citations per article. 53,877 references were used in the set of articles, these, only 18 sources 20 occurrences or more. A keyword analysis indicated that the term “competitive advantage” separates the zone of trivial information from the zone of research noise. Conclusion: Green marketing research has a temporal thematic progression characterized by five stages: consumer behavior, green marketing, sustainable development, and green products.

 

 

Study Purpose: The objective of this study is to analyze Journal of Marketing’s (JM) publications, identifying elements that can be used in high impact research and in the academic environment. Methodology / approach: In this bibliometric study 123 papers from JM and 9,351 references used by them were analyzed. The paper’s analysis included authors and their countries, institutions, editors, supports, methodologies, keywords, themes and structures from the titles, abstracts and results. The references’ analysis included the journals, the themes, the publication’s cycles and the frequencies. Relevance / originality: High-impact journals publication is sought after by researchers from the different areas of knowledge. In Marketing, the JM is the journal with the highest academic impact and its publications tend to indicate the state of the art in Marketing. Main results: Authors Rajdeep Grewal and Jan Wieseke published the most. The methodology used was predominantly quantitative The most frequent themes were “Products, Brands, Communication and Price” and ” Marketing Strategies and International Marketing”. 27% of the references were published less than 5 years before the article and 35% were repeated in more than two papers. The main references by topic are also presented. Theoretical / methodological contributions: The results allow (1) researchers to adjust their work, increasing the possibility of high impact publications, (2) academics to identify references for high quality teaching, and (3) national journals to reflect on how to expand their relevance.

 

 

In recent years, the rise of e-commerce has prompted the emergence of electronic marketplaces, or e-marketplaces, which act as intermediaries in the buying and selling process, bringing together several vendors to offer a wide range of products and services to customers, generating modalities such as business-to-business (B2B), business-to-consumer (B2C) or consumer-to-consumer (C2C) e-marketplaces. E-marketplaces offer advantages such as access to potential buyers, business and product visibility, the reduction of transaction costs, the comparison of offers and prices among competitors, and the ease of business internationalization. However, the success of e-marketplace business models depends on the sustainability of these platforms, which must involve different stakeholders in order to meet economic, environmental, and social objectives. Therefore, this study presents a bibliometric analysis and systematic review of e-marketplaces, open innovation, and sustainability for the last ten, five, and two years. The analysis includes the number, types, and subject areas of documents published each year, as well as considerations such as the most-cited publications and the leading authors, journals, countries, and institutional affiliations. The analysis also includes a study of the relevant concepts in the publications and their relationships, identifying the predominant topics related to e-marketplaces, open innovation, and sustainability. The results indicate a focus on subject areas such as social sciences, environmental sciences, energy, business, management, and accounting, which is consistent with the economic, environmental, and social dimensions of sustainability. The findings show that e-marketplaces, open innovation, and sustainability are closely related to concepts such as sustainable development, e-commerce, digital marketing, China (the leading country in terms of publications in all periods), logistics, supply chain management, big data, planning, and decision making. Future works should address traffic congestion and environmental impact, new delivery practices in last-mile logistics, and the motives for users’ engagement in e-marketplaces. Likewise, future research can be oriented toward sustainability dimensions and stakeholders’ integration through open innovation and toward the limitations of SMEs in order to access and benefit from digital platforms.

 

 

The main objective of this research is to establish the most important advances and research related to the discipline of innovation and service marketing through scientific production within the restaurant industry through a bibliometric study of the literature in which It combined the incidence of the topics innovation and marketing of services within this very particular industry. The methodology used for this article was through a systematic review that focused particularly on the study and analysis of the literature through a bibliometric study where it was possible to include research carried out at an empirical and retrospective level. These articles were extracted from the LENS.ORG database. It concludes by stating that it is essential to understand the processes related to innovation, transforming ideas into facts, and facts into market positioning. Innovating is being able to visualize all those situations in a way to do things faster, cheaper and easier; while the marketing study presented strategic frameworks in the continuous search for both the service offered, as well as the satisfaction perceived by customers.

 

 

Companies have adopted green marketing and marketing strategies to position themselves in consumer preferences and combat the problem of accelerated consumption of resources that has compromised the planet’s regenerative capacity, where the circular economy emerges as a solution to move towards responsible production and consumption patterns. From waste recycling marketing strategies, a descriptive analysis of 120 documents from the SCOPUS database was carried out using bibliometric techniques to know the existing state of the art for the period 1977-2021. The results indicate that the annual scientific production increased in the last ten years by over 200% for 2019, highlighting the USA, China, UK, Germany, and India, and Mexico is in position 22. The conceptual and trend analysis points out the relationship between marketing, waste management, commercialization, recycling, sustainable development, and circular economy, topics that have deepened research in the last 5 years due to the SDGs. Through intellectual analysis, schools of thought were identified, highlighting Chen, Wang, Zhang and Liu, Lu, and White as the most influential and connected with other authors. The results show no link between the study areas, but rather that they are developed in isolation, evidencing an area of opportunity to work on marketing strategies for waste recycling, where companies adopt circular economy objectives, obtaining an advantage. Competitive position and position in the market by offering products from a valorization that the consumer prefers.

 

 

The purpose of this article is to analyze the most productive and influential countries engaging in market orientation (MO) research between 1990 and 2016. This article shows the general trajectories of these countries, the relationships among them, and their research in the area of MO by analyzing results on citations and publications. The article uses applied bibliometric techniques on available information found in the Web of Science. The results show that the 10 leading countries produce more than 70% of total publications, where the United States leads in all indicators, followed by the United Kingdom and China. Furthermore, although there has been a steady increase in overall number of publications, this trend is not shared evenly among different nations.

 

 

This article aims to identify the main aspects discussed by scholars regarding business model components. The methodology used was a bibliometric study, based on the Law of Zipf, whose keywords form “Business model” and “components”. Data were collected from the Capes scientific journals database from 2009 to 2014 and from the Web of Science database. The extracted articles underwent descriptive analysis and the data extracted from the Web of Science were processed through Bibexcel Software, in which it was possible to generate a citation matrix that was managed by the Ucinet64 software, generating a list of authors by importance according to the number of citations and their respective relations of co-citations. The results allowed to identify the main research streams about business model components addressed by the scholars, highlighting value proposition, clients, infrastructure, resources, revenue model and costs.

 

 

Literature in marketing strategy suggests that the concept of atmospherics, traditionally restricted to the store’s physical environment, can also be applied to the digital context, modulating consumer behavior in e-commerce. This work therefore carried out a bibliometric analysis of theoretical and empirical articles (national and international) published in the last 16 years on e-atmospherics, using five electronic databases of periodicals. It was identified 27 articles whose analysis of the bibliometric variables adopted for this study (year, approach, outline, instruments, theoretical framework and origin) did not identify significant associations; therefore, although having theoretical and strategic importance, little has been researched, developed and applied in this theme. Particularly noteworthy is the incipience of works in the area conducted in a Brazilian context.

 

 

Research proposal: To present an overview of the use of photo-elicitation in marketing studies and to guide future researchers about the use of audiovisual methods. Methodology/approach: This work has an exploratory approach and, to give more robustness to the theoretical revision, a bibliometric research was carried out. Main results: The results indicate that photo-elicitation is applied in conjunction with other research techniques, with greater use in the self-driven format associated with in-depth interviews. The use of visual techniques is increasing, and also the use of software for better data analysis and presentation of results, which favors application in future marketing research. Theoretical/methodological contributions: Since the researches that use photo-elicitation in marketing are diverse and multifaceted, this study intends to contribute in order to organize and classify them in a judicious way. This may help other researchers who wish to use photo-elicitation as a technique for collecting data in their studies. Relevance/originality: Despite the wealth of information that audiovisual resources can provide, it is noted that there are still few authors in the field of marketing who are dedicated to such an application. This work collaborates with the discussions about techniques of data collection in marketing in the literature of research methodology.

 

 

Marketing researchers have the responsibility to promote their field of study, developing models and tools, and suggesting best practices that favour marketing practitioners as well. In this sense, both current practices and consumer behavior are investigated. However, consumer behavior should not be seen as a whole on itself. Based on this issue, we investigated the publication in marketing in Brazil. Through a desk research using bibliometric analysis techniques over 520 journal issues and 28 conference proceedings were analyzed. In order to evaluate the evolution of the publication in marketing, we selected the two oldest management journals (RAUSP of FEA/USP and RAE of EAESP/FGV) and the three main national events in the area (SEMEAD, EnANPAD and EMA). Papers published between 1947 and 1976 in RAUSP were analyzed in printed editions. The others were obtained through the website of the events and of the journals. In all, 2,715 marketing articles were identified. We noticed that there is a growing concentration of studies on consumer behavior. Other authors point to this situation, stressing that excessive focus on consumer behavior might reduce studies on strategy and decision making. Thus, the results suggest that marketing scholars rethink the scope of the field and their research activities, strengthening more applied studies to the reality of managers.

 

 

The work’s purpose was mapping and analyzing the academic production concerning the greenwashing subject. Thus, a theoretical framework on green marketing and greenwashing has been developed. The method adopted was a bibliometric research and a critical analysis associated with critical analysis of the content of the articles found, targeting the academic publications on the greenwashing term and other correlates, in the main Business Administration events in Brasil (Semead, EnAnpad and EMA) and on the most acknowledged scientific databases worldwide (Proquest, Web of Science, Capes, Scopus, Scielo and Spell). Therefore, it has been possible to realize that the greenwashing subject, despite responding for a recent and relevant production, is still not very studied by the academy, especially in depth. In this sense, of the 42 articles identified, it was analyzed that only 17 actually work with the theme, and the others only mention it or work as superficially or as a backdrop. It was observed that the analysis focus of these 17 articles focused on the investigation and empirical identification of greenwashing or on possible aspects that influence or are influenced by this practice, such as market evaluation, role of the media and government and the impact on the consumer behavior. Considering this, new studies are concerning the subject, mainly from the perspective of how is it possible to undermine or combat this practice concerning the organizations, highlighting, also, the potentiality of negative impacts resulting from it both in society as a whole and in the organizational and consumer markets.

 

 

Customer engagement is one of the topics that most arouses the attention of marketing professionals and academics today. This article aimed to contribute to general knowledge on this topic by mapping scientific research in this area of knowledge. For this purpose, a bibliometric and network analysis was carried out, using as a source the records in the Scopus and Web of Science databases. The main conclusions show that, despite being a recent subject, the study of customer engagement has prospered significantly. Also, four main lines or currents of work were identified in which the interests of researchers on this topic are concentrated. Finally, the contributions, limitations, and agenda for future studies are presented.

 

 

This study reviews the franchising literature on emerging markets. We used the Bibliometrix R-package and VOSviewer software to perform a bibliometric analysis of 297 articles between 1989 and 2020 obtained from the Scopus database. We combined bibliometric coupling, historiographic citation, keyword co-occurrence, and conceptual thematic analysis, with a content analysis of the most cited articles based on total global and local citations. We identified two main research clusters: international franchising and social franchising. This article provides a deep understanding of the intellectual and conceptual structure of the academic field. It complements existing qualitative reviews and attempts at characterizations, and suggests future research directions.

 

 

The micro businesses possess a singular importance, due to the capacitance of generation of employment and revenues; useful in order that the productive apparatus is capable of energize the economic activity, in Ecuador and specially in, Jipijapa hat. The impact of the COVID-19, has been devastating in the economic development of the micro entrepreneurs. The COVID-19, it is an illness that has generated an economic unfavorable impact. The economic systems are to be a affected for this pandemic and the Latin American region, is considerate the hit more of all. In investigation this letter proposes carry out an update of the knowledge’s, to perceive which is the situation they present the micro entrepreneurs of the city of Jipijapa hat, Ecuador; concern to the impact of the COVID-19. as for your strategic planning. For such end an investigation is developed at exploratori; descriptive and documentary level, based one’s opinion on a bibliometric analysis found one’s bearings to the analysis of scientific articles, present results of the investigation of field to 250 micro businesses of the Jipijapa hat canton, of the province of Manabi for the sake of having a real sight of the problematic that meet face to face the managers micro, useful in the awareness of the need to outline strategies for your fortification, innovation and reach of the main characteristics that are necessary to create competitive advantages and position in the market.

 

 

The purpose of this document is to explore the intellectual structure of viral marketing, its evolution and research trends. To this end, using scientometric techniques and tools, an analysis of citations was made, based on 188 publications on the subject, from 2000 to 2020, in the Web of Science database. This article identifies three sub-areas that have emerged from the literature. The first one focused on the factors that generate influence in the consumers’ decision making, when interacting with the content generated by the company; the second, explores how viral marketing has been enhanced by the advent of social networks; finally, the third one studies the use of influencers as a dynamic element in campaigns of this type. This work explores the intersection between the discipline of marketing and the use of social networks, especially as the latter are an element for the propagation of the messages of companies and consumers.

 

 

Several studies have empirically explored the association between practices in sustainable tourism and their impact on tourism marketing. However, bibliometric studies that organize the production in this field are still scarce. The objective of this study is thus to provide a bibliometric analysis of research on sustainable practices in tourism related to marketing, identifying the state of the art, trends and other indicators, by monitoring the articles published on the Web of Science (WoS) platform. A sample of 694 materials was obtained. The data were processed and the results graphically illustrated using the VOSviewer software. The study analyzed the simultaneous occurrence of publications by year, keyword trends, cocitations, bibliographic coupling and analysis of coauthorship, countries and institutions, and indicates that the literature on tourism sustainability issues in the field of tourism marketing is growing at a quick pace; merely five papers accounted for more than 2193 citations, but there are several prolific authors. Of the 694 sources included in the review, the most important ones published 40.34% of the papers; Spain is the leading country in this topic. This research provides insight about the state of the art and identifies gaps and research opportunities in sustainability and tourism marketing.

 

 

Objective: This study aims at analyzing the Brazilian scientific production of qualitative research in Marketing. Method: A thorough bibliometric review was conducted considering the A2 national journals of Administration in the decade from 2010 to 2019. The final analysis was carried out on a corpus of 82 empirical articles that adopted a qualitative research approach. Originality/Relevance: The analysis of the research corpus covered the fundamental criteria for conducting qualitative research: paradigmatic orientation, the place of theory, research method, types of data collection and analysis, and research quality criteria. Results: Given the analyzed aspects, the Brazilian marketing production based on qualitative research shows a significant difference between positivist and non-positivist orientations in terms of the adoption of data collection and analysis techniques, of research quality, and in the way how to use theory. Theoretical/methodological contributions: This duality indicates two different models for the use of qualitative research. Positivist orientation studies adopt a standard model, which emulates the logic of quantitative research. The non-positivist research, in turn, shows a more expansive and varied posture, as well as with greater care in terms of rigo

 

 

Avocado’s global acceptance has grown, resulting in expanding cultivation, agricultural development, and significant marketing efforts. Publicizing avocado also targets its by-products’ nutritional and functional benefits. This is the first bibliometric analysis for avocado. It aims to provide a descriptive structure to identify collaborative patterns and emerging themes in avocado research. Based on the search string used in the article title, the study retrieved 2576 documents from the Scopus database for further analysis. For comparison, we separated the data into two study periods: 1916–2011 and 2012–2021. BibliometriX and VOSviewer software were used to examine the descriptive structure and collaborative patterns, as well as to create maps based on network data. When we compared the two study periods, we identified a changing pattern in descriptive structure, collaboration and research trends. Based on the identified emergent themes of the last decade, we propose that future research focuses on the functional and medicinal properties of avocado, postharvest management and its biological control, plant cultivars and diseases, and physicochemical properties of avocado and its by-products. Further bibliographic support revealed that, in addition to the fruit pulp, non-edible parts of Persea americana (bark, leaves, peel, seeds, and stem), and oil have remarkable concentrations of bioactive compounds with potential biological activity for health benefits.

 

 

The purpose of this article is to identify research trends in branding and brand building focused on the elderly, considering the importance of knowledge of this consumer segment, based on the sociodemographic changes corresponding to the population structure in the world. For this purpose, a bibliometric analysis was carried out using the Scopus database and developed with the R Core Team 2020 -Bibliometrix software, followed by a qualitative systematic review of the PRISMA type. The results show that there is a recent interest in research on the study of branding and related topics of consumer analysis of the elderly segment, although it still has a low level of scientific production. The findings identify as the most relevant topics those associated with brand equity, brand image, market orientation, relationship marketing strategies, market segmentation, and senior consumer behavior. Regarding brand image, the most characteristic aspects of the studies are related to age psychographics, cognitive processes, self-confidence and boldness. From the previous review, it is recognized the relevance of making greater research efforts to respond to the need for knowledge about the behavior of the older adult consumer, since there are few studies that allow identifying the influences, processes and behavioral patterns of this market segment in the world.

 

 

Marketing is the social and managerial process through which individuals obtain what they need and want in creating and exchanging products. The literature on food consumer behavior has been receiving significant interest during the covid-19 pandemic, and studies highlight diverse research on business. This article seeks to examine the covid-19 pandemic and its implications for the food consumer behavior in Brazil. To that end, the Methodi Ordinatio was applied to identify the most relevant studies in the area, which supported the research, analysis, selection and systematic reading of 25 articles identified in Web of Science and Scopus databases. vosviewer and EndNote software were used in this study for the reference management process and clustering themes and researchers. Our findings show the importance of advances in vaccination, an increase in home office work, home food safety practices, and an increase in food purchases in supermarkets. We conclude that the main financial problems faced during this period are unemployment and debt, while the increased use of food delivery apps emerges as an opportunity. Recent studies mention environmental awareness, sustainable consumption, and social responsibility as key topics. As a suggestion for future research, the authors recommend marketing research involving the regulatory role of pro-social consumption and family farming in times of covid-19.

 

 

Objective. To examine marketing research production and its relationship with export processes in organizations between 1961 and 2020. Methodology. Several criteria for scientific production in the subject of study are proposed, and different bibliometric indicators were analyzed with the Bibliometrix (R statistical programming) and VOSviewer tools, yielding 289 documents through the Scopus bibliographic database. Results. The study identified elements such as the main and secondary nodes in the co-occurrence of keywords, the main sources of publication in the topics studied, the authors who contributed the most per country, and the articles with the greatest impact. Conclusions. Since 2000, there has been a significant increase in research on marketing related to export processes in organizations; a minor portion of the total production is focused on researching the areas studied in small and medium-sized enterprises.

 

 

This study aims to identify the evolution, trends and research agenda in city brand research. The methodology used was a science mapping bibliometric and network analysis using both, WoS and Scopus databases, to do a systematic literature review. The results of this analysis resulted in four possible perspectives in the research on city brand: Marketing of city brand, Residents and city brand, Governance of city brand and Economic and social impact of city brand. Like all bibliometric studies, this one has limitations due to its specific methodology, such as the consultation of databases that possibly excluded other studies that could offer a broader panorama, likewise, the analysis network methodology proposed perspectives that they can also be limited and exclusive. This study presents a novelty of the bibliometric analysis tool in the city brand research.

 

 

Several studies explored the effect of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) on marketing. However, bibliometric research that organizes this production is scarce. Thus, this study aims to provide a bibliometric view of marketing-related CSR research, identifying this field’s state-of-the-art literature. Two thousand and forty-two articles were collected through the Web of Science (WoS) platform. Data were analyzed using VOSviewer software to map the data graphically. The results show that: (a) the literature on CSR in the marketing area is growing; (b) five articles alone accounted for 9940 citations, and there are several prolific authors; (c) the prominent journals identified in this research published 42.16% of the total; (d) The “Journal of Business Ethics” is the leader in the number of publications, followed by “Sustainability,” which has shown strong growth in recent years, and; (e) The US is the leading country, according to the number of articles and citations. The keyword trending network analysis revealed that CSR is becoming a strategic marketing approach for companies. This study offers an insight into the state-of-the-art and trends identification in CSR and marketing.

 

 

The purpose of this bibliometric study is to investigate the state of the art in the subject of sustainable marketing in the scientific search engines Scopus and Web of Science. A literature search was carried out in the aforementioned search engines. The applied methodology was the bibliometric technique using different refinement criteria to obtain the information, the keywords “sustainability” and “marketing” were used as a search method in the titles, abstracts and keywords. Of the selected documents, it was also refined by areas of interest and the period 2016 to 2021 was considered, resulting in 1,310 documents in Scopus and 1,992 in Web Of Science, giving a total of 3302 the final sum of both amounts. The main findings, the sustainable marketing issue is a frontier issue in the sciences that is growing in the last 6 years, which has been applied in the business and academic world, various business opportunities were detected, in which the innovation, knowledge, emerging markets, business models, market orientation, consumer behavior, stakeholder, and social and corporate responsibility are the area’s most closely related to sustainable marketing. Limitations which study only includes the literature of the aforementioned search engines and the criteria established in the methodology.

 

 

Purpose: This paper studies, based on the theory of service-dominant logic, the effect of value co-creation practices (linking and materializing) on engagement dimensions (popularity, commitment and virality). The main objective is to analyze the influence of value co-creation practices on engagement at international trade shows organizer association on Twitter. Design/methodology/approach: This paper studies the usage of Twitter by the Specialty Food Association, which organizes one of the top five foods and beverage international trade show in the United States. To achieve the research objective, the authors have analyzed 1,608 posts on Twitter from the Twitter account @Specialty_Food. A content analysis was performed using Krippendorff’s (2004) recommendations, and the data were analyzed using regression analysis with optimal scaling and Kruskal–Wallis Test. Findings: According to the results, some materializing practices influence popularity, commitment, virality and global engagement on Twitter. While the usage of some linking practices influences respectively commitment and popularity. Originality: These results provide valuable information for business-to-business (B2B) contexts and answer a research gap reported in previous literature, which affirms that more research is needed about the relationship between service systems and engagement. From a general view, to generate more engagement on social media in B2B contexts, it is recommended to prioritize posts that incorporate live and online events based on collaborative and dynamic human interactions, following by business ideas and business cases.

 

 

Introduction: the evolution of Information and Communication Technologies has generate changes in society, such as marketing and advertising activities. The expansion of Internet access and the popularization of the use of equipment like personal computers and smartphones led companies to develop digital marketing. This study aims to build a bibliographic portfolio of digital transformations that allow us to understand how technological advances are transforming marketing and advertising practices. Method: : it uses the ProKnow-C methodology to build knowledge, and it the search was made at Scopus database. It retrieved 566 articles considering the search strategy used, and 221 articles related to the research objectives were selected. After applying the selection and exclusion criteria, 41 studies made the bibliographic portfolio. Results: the bibliometric analysis shows the heterogeneity of authors and the concentration of research in the United States of America and Europe. Conclusions: considering the portfolio, it recommends investigating the possibilities of creating experiences of deep involvement with consumers in marketing and advertising practices, especially with the use of Virtual Reality technology, generating experience marketing.

 

 

The expansion of the internet over the last few decades has been accompanied by a wide range of ethical discussions. In the culture of social media, the buying and selling of friends, followers, likes and views has become frequent. The question that arises is whether these goods, actions and behaviors may or may not be bought, as well as what the consequences of this market, it operations and what it represents. The objective of this investigation is to point out that the market can only acquire the appearance of these goods and that the internet, when it becomes a place of appearances, loses credibility and gains distrust. Through a methodology based on bibliographic research, as well as on internet sites and statistical data collection, it is concluded that this market is immoral and detrimental to the virtual environment and to social life.

 

 

The training of management students in Brazil is centered on managerial aspects of marketing and, because of this, graduates seem unable to deal with the complexity of the applications of marketing knowledge. Thus, the present research sought to incorporate experimentally the social marketing contents within the discipline of marketing administration in the undergraduate degree in administration, in order to analyze their contributions in the formation of the students. For this, the research took place in two distinct stages: first, a social marketing seminar was conducted within the discipline of marketing administration; tthen, focus groups were carried out in order to obtain a comparison between the dimensions: deficient market conceptualization, disconnection between marketing and society, and uncritical vision, proposed by Bernadinelli and Sauberbron (2017) for the training of the administrator. At the end of the research, it was concluded that social marketing teaching provided students with a better understanding of marketing as a broad-based science, significantly reducing the separation between marketing and society and the stakeholder roles that make up the market.

 

 

Purpose: This study analyzes and categorizes the scientific production in the field of digital marketing in the specific context of small and medium enterprises. Design/methodology: We retrieved the bibliographic information of 294 publications in this field indexed in Scopus database and employed technology-mining techniques and cluster analysis of keywords to gain insights into the most relevant trends in this research area. We conducted a keyword cleaning process to remove ambiguity, synonyms, and obvious results and employed our own Python scripts and the Bibliometrix package in the R programming language for the calculations. Findings: Our results depict a broad picture of this research area, highlighting the most important journals, countries, researchers, and keywords, as well as their interactions. We also identified and explained five thematic clusters: electronic commerce, social media, corporate websites, internationalization, and brand. We found that social media, big data, search engine optimization, advertisement, internationalization, websites, and Facebook are hot research topics in this field.In addition, we present a number of pending research questions in the field related to thematic and methodological issues. Originality/value: This study offers updated information on the trends of the scientific production in the above mentioned research field, covering a time window from 1989 until 2021. This review goes beyond existing traditional bibliometric analysis, and reveals the structure of the knowledge in the field. This paper is expected to be used as a reference point from which to define a future research agenda in this area.

 

 

The COVID-19 crisis is among the most disruptive events in recent decades. Its profound consequences have garnered the interest of many studies in various disciplines, including consumer behavior, thereby warranting an effort to review and systematize the literature. Thus, this study systematizes the knowledge generated by 70 COVID-19 and consumer behavior studies in the Scopus database. It employs descriptive analysis, highlighting the importance of using quantitative methods and China and the US as research settings. Co-occurrence analysis further identified various thematic clusters among the studies. The input-process-output consumer behavior model guided the systematic review, covering several psychological characteristics and consumer behaviors. Accordingly, measures adopted by governments, technology, and social media stand out as external factors. However, revised marketing strategies have been oriented toward counteracting various consumer risks. Hence, given that technological and digital formats mark consumer behavior, firms must incorporate digital transformations in their process. © 2021